Map or Simulation? - Turning Maps into Games

Some of the most imaginative maps appearing on the web right now are doing much more than showing us where things are. They're turning real cities into miniature virtual worlds, complete with changing weather, animated traffic, shifting daylight and streets we can actually explore.

Three particularly impressive examples demonstrate just how far this new breed of interactive cartography is going:

  • Isometric Bielsko-Biała – A gorgeous SimCity-style pixel-art rendering of a Polish city, complete with changing seasons, weather and animated buses.

  • Atlas Above – Beautifully stylised renderings of Kiev, Amsterdam, Berlin, Hamburg, Munich and Vienna, offering a striking alternative to conventional 3D mapping.

  • Warsaw in Voxels – A Minecraft-inspired diorama of central Warsaw where you can change the weather, explore the streets and even click on pedestrians to "possess" them and walk around the city.

What makes these projects particularly interesting is that they are built using real geographic data, including OpenStreetMap building footprints, LiDAR elevation models and municipal datasets. Yet spend a few minutes exploring them and you realise something: these aren't really maps. They're simulations.

And they point to an interesting convergence between cartography, game development and creative coding.


When Maps Become Game Worlds

For years, cartographers and GIS analysts have used geographic data to help us understand and navigate the real world. Game developers, meanwhile, build virtual environments, often painstakingly modelling cities and landscapes or generating them procedurally.

That distinction is disappearing.

OpenStreetMap, 3D terrain tiles and freely available LiDAR data now provide developers with an enormous ready-made library of real-world environments. Armed with Three.js, WebGL and WebGPU, creative coders are turning these datasets into interactive digital playgrounds.

Projects such as Isometric Bielsko-Biała and Warsaw in Voxels go well beyond displaying buildings. They introduce dynamic lighting, changing seasons, weather, animated vehicles and pedestrians. Geographic data becomes the raw material for miniature living worlds.

But Are They Actually Good Maps?

If your objective is navigation or spatial analysis, many of these projects are surprisingly poor maps.

Consider the animated traffic and pedestrians. Our eyes are naturally drawn to movement, making animation one of the most powerful visual variables available. But when developers populate a scene with randomly moving cars and pedestrians simply to make it feel alive, the result is visual noise rather than useful information.

Edward Tufte, the influential statistician and data-visualisation expert, has long argued against unnecessary graphical decoration that distracts from the information being presented. His concept of chartjunk seems particularly relevant here. When animated cars and wandering pedestrians aren't representing real-world data, they add visual clutter without adding knowledge.

Unless that traffic represents genuine data, it tells us nothing about congestion or mobility. It's essentially cartographic chartjunk.

But perhaps that's missing the point.

They're Not Trying to Be Maps

The developers behind these projects aren't necessarily trying to solve traditional cartographic problems. They're creative coders and graphics programmers asking a different question: how can we turn real-world geography into an atmospheric, explorable world inside a web browser?

A traditional map abstracts the world so we can understand it from the outside. A simulation reconstructs it so we can explore it from the inside.

These projects are digital dioramas, interactive and playable urban environments. Judged as conventional maps, they might fall short. Judged as experiments in making geography immersive, they're impressive.

What Cartographers Could Learn

There's more to learn from these simulations than how to make buildings look prettier on a map. They also offer some interesting ideas about how we interact with geographic information.

  • Make Maps Immersive: Rather than simply displaying buildings and roads, create environments that people can explore. Let users wander through a city, fly over a landscape or experience a place from street level.

  • Bring Geography to Life: Changing weather, moving traffic, seasonal vegetation and shifting daylight can communicate aspects of a place that a static map cannot. The important distinction is to make these effects meaningful rather than merely decorative.

  • Experiment with Visual Styles: These projects demonstrate that geographic data doesn't have to look like a conventional map. Pixel art, voxels and miniature 3D worlds can all provide new ways to interpret and communicate geography.

Perhaps the biggest lesson is that we shouldn't always think of maps as just things to look at. They can also be things to inhabit and explore. Geographic data can be the foundation of an experience, not just the subject of a map. And that's an exciting possibility for the future of cartography.

Comments

Popular Posts